What
is a Brownfield?
The federal government defines brownfields as "abandoned, idled or
underused industrial and commercial properties where expansion or
redevelopment is complicated by real or perceived environmental
contamination." Brownfields may make you think of dirty, blighted,
abandoned industrial property, but that image is too narrow. Though
some brownfields are old industrial sites, others are commercial
buildings with little or no environmental contamination. Brownfields
could be former service stations, warehouses, abandoned railroads or
air strips.
Do I own a
Brownfield?
Ask yourself: Is my land idle, vacant, or less productive than it
ought to be? Are concerns about environmental contamination
contributing to the problem? If you answered yes to both questions,
then you might own a brownfield.
What is a Greenfield?
Greenfields are areas of land that have not previously been
developed, such as woodlands, farmlands, or fields that are
typically on the outskirts of urban areas. Many businesses and
industries prefer developing greenfields to avoid the complications
involved with brownfields specifically and, in general, with
development in urban areas. Extensive development of greenfields,
particularly combined with underdevelopment of brownfields and other
infill properties, can intensify problems of urban sprawl.
How does a
community benefit from brownfield redevelopment?
Brownfield redevelopment can help a community in many ways. Many
brownfields sites are in unattractive, economically depressed parts
of a neighborhood. Cleanup and redevelopment of the sites can
encourage higher property values and create jobs, as well as
positively impact the local economy by creating a safer, healthier
urban space to house businesses and residences.
What are the
benefits of brownfield redevelopment to property owners?
In addition to providing benefits to surrounding communities,
property owners that clean up and reuse their brownfield properties
may benefit directly by:
-
Avoiding potential environmental enforcement actions by federal,
state and local regulatory agencies that could impose penalties
and costly cleanups;
-
Receiving tax benefits for cleaning up and reusing the property;
-
Reducing the likelihood that contamination from the property
will migrate off site or into the groundwater under the site,
thereby limiting liability for, and long term costs of, cleaning
up the property;
-
Creating good will within the community
-
Reducing the potential need to address liabilities associated
with the property in financial statements and Securities and
Exchange Commission filings;
-
Realizing an enhanced return from the property by making it more
valuable and marketable.
Where are
Brownfields located?
Brownfields are found all across the country, but are concentrated
primarily in urban areas. They may be former gas stations or dry
cleaning facilities, or former industrial properties where at one
point hazardous substances may have been used.
How many
brownfields are there nationwide?
According to estimates made by the United States General Accounting
Office, there are as many as 425,000 throughout the U.S.; however, it is difficult to
estimate with any certainty the number of brownfield properties.
Other estimates suggest that there are 5 million acres of abandoned
industrial property in urban areas.
Who is involved
in brownfield redevelopment?
A variety of private and public sector organizations may play a role
in the course of cleaning up and redeveloping Brownfield sites. Not
all of these organizations will be involved at every site. Key
players include: state environmental agencies, state economic
development and planning agencies, citizen and community groups,
commercial lenders, technical consultants, legal counsel, local
government agencies, developers, investors, real estate
professionals, local community development corporations, and federal
government agencies, such as the U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency.
What are state
and local agencies doing to aid Brownfields redevelopment?
Many state economic development agencies have incentive programs
that focus funding on assessment, cleanup, basic construction, and
infrastructure development for Brownfield sites. In some instances,
these programs are designed exclusively for Brownfield applicants;
in other instances, more broadly defined redevelopment funding
programs give special preference or priority to Brownfield site
applicants. Larger cities are also beginning to have their own
Brownfield programs, including tax incentives for cleaning up
Brownfields. In addition, some local governments use tax increment
financing, or TIFs, to dedicate taxes to secure financing for
development activities. Such programs may include Brownfields
redevelopment tasks, such as site assessments. The rules for TIFs
vary by jurisdiction, but generally they allow local governments to
issue bonds to finance development costs in a specific area, such as
site improvements or infrastructure.
Are there tax
incentives for Brownfields redevelopment?
In addition to direct financial assistance, federal, state and local
tax incentives are available to property owners and developers to
help reduce the costs of Brownfield projects. The federal tax
incentives include the Taxpayers Relief Act, which allows eligible
taxpayers to deduct qualified cleanup expenses at eligible
Brownfields in the year they are incurred, and rehabilitation income
tax credits for 10% of the expenses of rehabilitating structures
built before 1936. Many state and local governments also provide tax
breaks for Brownfield projects.
What is the
role of insurance in Brownfields transactions?
Insurance can help reduce the risk for many of the key players in a
Brownfield transaction, thereby facilitating cleanup and
redevelopment. For example, insurance can reduce the risk to a
property owner who wants to sell a property but is concerned about
potential liability for environmental contamination discovered after
the sale. Insurance can also help reduce a prospective buyer's risk
of potential liability for cleanup or for personal injury and
property damage claims. These and other kinds of insurance are
increasingly helping to encourage lenders to provide loans for
contaminated properties. In addition, insurance can be used to
reduce the risk of potential liability of cleanup contractors. The
new insurance products vary based on the particular policy and
insurer, but the following general types of insurance are most
commonly used in brownfield transactions: cleanup cost cap
insurance, environmental impairment insurance and secured creditor
insurance.
How clean is
clean - must a Brownfield site be cleaned up to pristine conditions?
The extent of cleanup will vary considerably depending on the type,
amount and area of contamination, and the cleanup standards used by
the specific regulatory program that governs the cleanup. In
addition, a key factor in determining the level of cleanup is
whether the use of the property is taken into account in setting
cleanup standards. For example, if a property is slated for
industrial use, the cleanup standards may be less stringent than if
the property were to be used for residential purposes, because the
level of exposure to the contaminants will be less.
How much will
the cleanup cost?
The cost of the cleanup will vary considerably depending on many
factors. The level, type, amount, and extent of contamination are
key determinants. For example, if the groundwater under the site is
contaminated, the cost of cleanup is likely to be much higher than
if just the soil is contaminated. If the contaminated materials need
to be transported off site for treatment that will also affect the
cost. The cost will also depend on the standards that apply to the
cleanup, particularly whether the use of the property is considered
in setting cleanup levels. If a Brownfield property is cleaned up to
commercial use standards, for example, rather than residential use
standards, the cleanup will typically be less expensive. The cost to
the property owner of the cleanup will also be affected by whether
there are other parties, such as previous owners of the property,
that are also responsible for the contamination and can contribute
to the costs.
How long will
the cleanup take?
The length of the cleanup will vary according to the level, type,
amount and extent of the contamination, as well as the cleanup
standards that apply to the site. A site with extensive soil and
groundwater contamination that is cleaned up to residential
standards is likely to take longer to clean up than a site that has
only minimal contamination and will be used for industrial purposes.
Factors such as the time of year, or unusually bad weather can
affect the duration of the cleanup. In most cases, technical
consultants will be hired to perform the cleanup. The pace of the
cleanup will also be contingent in part on the consultants'
schedules and levels of efficiency.